I asked this question on another post recently and received a litany of great answers. I am well aware that there really is no criteria to who gets a book, but each of us has their own criteria of what really merits a book. I for one am not here to pass along my thoughts on the subject because each of us has different views and it becomes a personal choice more than anything else. I found two books recently that come from two ends of the spectrum on the field, but give the reader a very similar product in the end.
Ralph Mauriello and Ron Fairly have several things in common. Most notably they are both Dodgers Alumni, and I have noticed the feeling of once a Dodger, always a Dodger. But their careers took very different paths throughout the years. While Mauriello had a short stint with the Major League team, he spent the majority of his playing years toiling in the minors, while Fairly put a couple of decades at the big league level with a few different stops around the league. Now with such different playing careers and reaching different levels of success you would thing the end resulting books of their lives would be wildly different. I am glad to say that could not be further from the truth.
Now that is not to say that both books are mirror images, but there are certain important qualities that shine through. They both share their life and career experiences for the reader which helps give a well-rounded view of what they offered on the field. This comes in especially helpful those readers that may not have been around during their playing days, it paints a picture in your mind of what baseball was like for each author as they made their way along their unique journey. Both books also illustrate what great men both players were, the humility they had, both on and off the field and the honor it was for both of them to be part of the game they loved. Family is also an important factor in both men’s lives and it is showcased very clearly in both books. Finally, both books show what life is like after you are off the field. While both men have taken very different paths in life you can see the underlying love of the game and the immense pride they both had to be on that field.
When I asked the who deserves a book question previously I thought I had a better handle on the answer . Today I realize if you have a story to tell, no matter what their contribution to the game was, it’s a story worth telling. It’s up to the readers to decide which stories that they want to read and what they find worthy of their time. If it is a 20 year veteran or a cup of coffe player, they still have a lot to offer the readers. For my money these both books make the cut.
If you like the Dodgers and the early years of California baseball, along with a spattering of stories about celebrities and baseball royalty then these books would be for you. They both tell great stories throughout flow very nicely and you get two different views of the Once a Dodger Always a Dodger tag.
You can get these great books at the following links:
When a team changes cities it is a daunting process. Ownership has to make sure it crosses all its T’s and dots all its I’s to make sure everything will be to their, and more importantly their fans liking. No where as near as common place as it once was, team transfers can be a great thing for those involved. New stadiums, new fan base, a whole new chance to invent yourself and the financial rewards usually aren’t too bad either. That is just what the New York giants were hoping for with their move to San Francisco. A shiny new stadium to call home accompanied with lots of parking spaces for ownership to sell each night helped sell them on their new locale. But sometimes all is not what you hope it will be, and todays book takes a look at the Giants move to California and good or bad, depending on where you stood, their new Home Sweet Home.
We are all well aware of the story of the Dodgers moving to Los Angeles and their conquering of the Southern California market. Sometimes lost in that great shadow is the Giants, who abandoned the Polo Grounds and the city of New York at the exact same time to help usher in baseball across the continent. Walter O’Malley was larger than life at times and in that shadow one can understand how Horace Stoneham may have fallen by the wayside. So with that, it easy to forget the history of the Giants during the first years in California. Luckily for us this book shows us what it took to get the Giants in place in San Fran and the hopes ownership had for the new frontier.
Robert Garrett does a good job of giving us the background of the team in New York and the situation it found itself in during the late 50’s. From stadium woes to the personality of Horace Stoneham you get a pretty good feel of what it was like for the team during their waning days in New York. He shows the courtship of the Giants by a new city and the promises bestowed by the local government, the biggest of all being a new stadium.
Stoneham had a somewhat of a hands off approach to his new stadium as the book shows and it in turn came to bite him in the butt. Candlestick Park had its own set of issues that are well chronicled in the book which in turn snowballed, enough so that it would essentially destroy many of the dreams of what Stoneham had for this new venture. In the end it is one of the driving factors that ends the Stoneham ownership of the team.
Next we look at the struggles to find new ownership and the quest to keep the Giants in San Francisco less than twenty years after the had arrived. Once new ownership was found you see the same struggles of old ownership with the albatross of Candlestick still dangling around its neck. It shows an interesting look at how baseball operated in regards to stadiums, success at the gate and play on the field. You see how the Giants, except for a few years as a whole, struggled while they called Candlestick home. It’s also shown how the people of San Fran really didn’t care if they ever got out of there.
Finally, you see a final change on ownership that get the Giants to a new frontier and a stadium worthwhile of Major League Baseball and the success that comes with that type of arena. I honestly think this book is a great look at this era of Giants baseball, no matter how bad it was on the field. It’s a portion of team history that gets overshadowed by the Los Angeles Dodgers moving at the same time, the expansion of baseball and the evolving changes that were going on in both baseball and society. It proves some dreams take longer than others to come to fruition.
If you have an interest in California baseball during this era this book is definitely worth checking out. You can get this book from the nice folks at the University of Nebraska Press.